Egypt’s NGO Laws Continue to Threaten Civil Society

The Al-Mawred Cultural Resource has shuttered some of its programs due to the recent anti-foreign financing legislation: Photo courtesy of the Al-Marwed Facebook page.
The Al-Mawred Cultural Resource has shuttered some of its programs due to the recent anti-foreign financing legislation: Photo courtesy of the Al-Marwed Facebook page.

By: Ahmed Naji

10-17-2014

In a paid advertisement published in Al-Ahram newspaper in September 2014, the Egyptian Ministry of Social Solidarity extended the deadline for NGOs to register with the government. This announcement extended the existing deadline by 45 days to mid-November; a July 2014 announcement had indicated that all NGOs must be registered with the government by September otherwise they will be subject to prosecution.

According to the 2002 civil society law (Law 2002-84), NGOs in Egypt are all subject to the supervision of the Ministry of Social Solidarity. This has created a situation in which the government monitors NGO’s activities instead of the other way around. The current civil society law is highly restrictive: It gives both the Ministry of Social Solidarity and the Ministry of Interior the authority to monitor and supervise the activities of any NGO. Their authority includes the ability to dismantle the elected board of any NGO, freeze an NGO’s assets, and revoke its license. It also gives representatives from both ministries the right to request the minutes of any NGO’s board meetings and mandates that any funding received by NGOs must first be approved the Ministry of Social Solidarity.

Currently, most human rights organizations in the country must operate as law firms or not-for-profit corporations. Under the Mubarak regime, the government allowed NGOs to operate within this legal grey area, while using the law to punish NGOs should they cross certain red lines. Even NGOs working in the realm of cultural and social development were subject to this oversight. Despite many attempts to reform the existing laws, the situation actually seems to be worsening, and there are fears that new policies will again be used to intimidate Egyptian civil society.

After the January 25 Revolution, many activists and civil society organizations demanded a new law that would maintain the freedom of Egyptian civil society. The struggle for new civil society laws continued after the June 30 Revolution, when former President Muhammed Morsi was deposed, leading to three different drafts being prepared in 2012, 2013, and 2014. However, a new civil society law has not yet been passed.

Then, in a surprise move in September 2014, the government passed an amendment to Article 78 of the Egyptian penal code, making penalties more severe against anyone who works for or receives any funds or support from local and international organizations “with the intention of committing acts harmful to national interest…or acts that breach the country’s independence, or unity, or territorial integrity, or committing attacks that disrupt public security and safety.”  Now penalties include a fine of no less than 500,000 EGP and the maximum penalty includes life imprisonment (or the death penalty if during a time of war or in support of terrorism).

This sudden introduction of new restrictions on civil society organizations has created a sense of panic among NGO workers, not only in human rights organizations but also in culture and arts organizations. For example, Al-Mawred, a cultural organization that has had a strong presence in supporting cultural activities in Egypt over the past ten years, has a program called Abbara, through which it finances five young cultural organizations. With the new civil society provisions, however, Al-Mawred has suspended all the program’s activities, and is now asking all its beneficiaries to assure their legal standing according to the Egyptian civil society law.

An unanswered question concerning the new laws is how open to interpretation they will be – experts seem to vary in their assessments. Gamal Eid, Executive Director of the Arabic Network for Human Rights, described the amendment as “an admission of the state’s desire to penalize individuals.” It “will bring darkness and silence to Egypt, heralding a phase that resembles the reigns of Saddam Hussein in Iraq and Moamar Gadhafi in Libya,” added Eid.

Similarly, Negad el-Borai, a lawyer, human rights activist, and former member of Egypt’s National Council for Human Rights, described the amendment to Article 78 as a violation of the existing penal code approved by the Supreme Constitutional Court, which states that penal codes must be articulated in a clear and specific manner, leaving no room for mystery or deception. This means that penal code provisions cannot be left open to interpretation or used for entrapment.

In contrast, Shehata Mohamed Shehata, Manager of the Arab Center for Integrity and Transparency, described the amendments as aiming to criminalize receiving money and the subsequent purchase of arms or ammunitions in support of terrorist organizations. He pointed out that these amendments do not infringe on civil society organizations or NGOs. This is also the opinion taken by Nasser Amin, who is a specialist in legal rights and President of the Arab Center for the Independence of the Judiciary and the Legal Profession. Amin stated that the law does not address civil society organizations or NGOs, which are subject to the civil society law (Law 2002-84). He added that the new provision is targeted towards terrorist organizations and individuals, with the aim of increasing their penalties.

Amidst this confusion, it seems that NGO’s employees must choose one of two evils: either be subject to monitoring and supervision by the Ministry of Interior or be open to the possibility of life in prison for receiving foreign funding. These amendments may be nominally aimed at curbing the work of organizations that address issues the government considers contentious, but they also mean that not-for-profit corporations that work in development, culture, or the arts may have no room in the new Egypt; many of these organizations depend on outside funding, which they will not be able to receive without running huge risks.

Although cloaked in the name of national security, the new provisions are nothing but a reincarnation of the old tactic of intimidating NGO workers and criminalizing their work. Many of those who work in NGOs are expecting the government to use the new law to strike out at them, but they have no idea when to expect such a move. In fact, the government may not actually end up shutting down NGOs or arresting their workers. It may instead actually use the law to fight terrorism. But the very fact that such a law exists nonetheless threatens Egyptian NGOs. Civil society laws continue to be a potential weapon in the authorities’ arsenal, which is enough to exert pressure on NGO employees. This pressure may affect the level to which they engage with rights issues and cases, which is particularly concerning given the recent increase in human rights violations by Egyptian authorities.

 

Ahmed Naji

Ahmed Naji

Novelist and journalist based in Egypt, works as an editor in the literary weekly Akhbar al-Adab.
Category: Commentary

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Latest on TIMEP

Standing in Agreement: Egypt’s Parliament Risks Becoming Rubber Stamp

A lack of quorum had already forced Egypt’s parliament to recess for 30 minutes when Speaker Ali Abdel ‘Al decided to call for two successive votes by show of hands and two more votes via standing in agreement. The absence of a live feed of the session hid the absurdity of Abdel ‘Al and his

TIMEP Announces Selection of Third TIMEP-Atlas Corps Bassem Sabry Democracy Fellow

The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy (TIMEP) is pleased to announce the selection of Mr. Hussein Baoumi as the recipient of the Bassem Sabry Democracy Fellowship. Mr. Baoumi is the third awardee of the fellowship and will be undertaking research on civil society organizations, human rights, and democratization in Egypt. Throughout his fellowship, beginning

The Great Game in Northern Syria

Almost exactly a year after Russia intervened militarily to prop up the regime of Bashar al-Assad, Turkish tanks rolled into the Syrian border city of Jarablus on Tuesday to help anti-government rebels expel the Islamic State from one of its most strategic strongholds. The operation, which drove out the militants eight hours after the battle

FY17 Tweaks to Egypt Aid Fall Short of Real Change

The fiscal year 2017 budget and appropriations process was an opportunity for the United States to reexamine its relationship with Egypt and structure its aid package accordingly. However, the past several months have unveiled a State Department and a Congress that have done little to repair a foreign policy toward Egypt that is mired in

Small Businesses Can Play a Big Role in Humanitarian Crises

If the 125 million people in need of humanitarian assistance around the world lived in a single country, it would represent the 11th-most populous nation on earth. The United Nations Secretary-General’s High-Level Panel on Humanitarian Financing—which I was humbled to serve on—noted this fact when it published the outcomes of its deliberations earlier this year.

TIMEP on Twitter

TIMEP on Facebook

Subscribe to our Mailing Lists

* indicates required